Car Insurance for Newcomers in Canada: What It Costs and How to Pay Less
Car insurance for newcomers in Canada usually costs more at first, because insurers can’t see a Canadian driving or claims record. In Ontario, the average premium was $2,218 a year as of June 2026, and a new arrival can be quoted more. Proof of your driving history from home, the right car and a few discounts can bring the price down. Here’s how it works in each province, as of November 2026.
Why is car insurance for newcomers in Canada so expensive?
Insurers price your risk. Ontario’s regulator, FSRA, lists the main factors:
- How long you’ve had a licence, plus past accidents, tickets and driver training
- The car you drive and how often it’s stolen or costly to repair
- Where you live (cities cost more because crashes and theft are more common)
- How much you drive, and whether you drive to work or school
- Your age, gender and marital status
- The coverage and deductibles you choose, and the insurer you pick
As a newcomer, you often have no Canadian record for the insurer to check, a brand-new provincial licence, and an address in a big city. Without a record to check, an insurer may price you like a less experienced driver. Even ICBC, which credits foreign experience, says it adjusts premiums for your first three years of driving in BC because of the risks of driving in a new area.
Tip: In Ontario, insurers can’t make you consent to a credit check before a quote, and they can’t use credit information for quotes or renewals. A thin credit file shouldn’t hurt your Ontario quote, but you still need credit for renting and loans. See our guide to building a credit score from zero.
Public vs private car insurance: who sells it in your province?
| Province | Mandatory coverage from | Minimum liability | Good to know |
|---|---|---|---|
| British Columbia | ICBC (Basic Autoplan) | $200,000 | Optional coverage from ICBC or private insurers |
| Manitoba | MPI (Basic Autopac) | Up to $500,000 | Optional coverage from MPI or private insurers |
| Saskatchewan | SGI (plate insurance) | $200,000 | You choose No Fault or Tort injury coverage (same price) |
| Quebec | SAAQ for injuries; private insurer for property damage | $50,000 (civil liability) | SAAQ coverage is paid through your licence and registration fees |
| Ontario | Private insurers | $200,000 | Big accident benefit changes on July 1, 2026 |
| Alberta | Private insurers | $200,000 | Moves to a “Care-First” model on January 1, 2027 |
| Nova Scotia | Private insurers | $500,000 | Includes accident benefits and uninsured motorist coverage |
| New Brunswick, PEI, NL, territories | Private insurers | $200,000 | Coverage packages vary by province or territory |
In the three public-insurer provinces, the price for basic coverage follows the public insurer’s rates, so shopping around mostly matters for optional coverage. In Ontario, Alberta and Atlantic Canada, every part of the price is competitive, and quotes can differ a lot.
Does your driving experience from home count for insurance?
British Columbia (ICBC): Yes. ICBC credits up to 15 years of non-BC driving experience (not counting learner time) toward Basic insurance discounts. You need a driver’s abstract or letter of experience from the licensing authority that issued your first full licence. ICBC says proof of previous insurance is not required. If more proof arrives later, licensing bodies in certain countries (including the US, UK, Australia, Japan and South Korea) can email or fax it straight to ICBC. Proof from other countries must be shown in person.
Manitoba (MPI): Bring a claims history letter from your previous insurer. MPI says it may help you get a premium discount. The letter should show the policyholder’s name, policy number and dates, all listed drivers, the insurer’s contact details, any claims, and the date issued. Also get your Manitoba licence first: MPI says if you buy Autopac before you have it, you can’t qualify for a premium discount.
Saskatchewan (SGI): SGI’s Safe Driver Recognition program gives safe drivers discounts of up to 25%. Ask SGI what records from home it can use for your rating.
Ontario and other private-insurer provinces: No rule forces insurers to count foreign experience. Each company decides. Some will consider a letter of experience from your previous insurer plus your official driving record. Others count only Canadian or US history. Ask every broker the same question: “Will you credit my driving experience from my home country, and what documents do you need?”
Money saver: Before you move, ask your home insurer for a letter on company letterhead listing your policy dates, drivers and claims (or “no claims”). Pair it with your official driving record. These are the same documents that help you exchange your foreign driver’s licence.
What car insurance coverage is mandatory in Canada?
Ontario’s standard policy includes $200,000 of third-party liability, statutory accident benefits, uninsured automobile coverage, and direct compensation for property damage (DCPD). Since January 2024 you may choose not to claim DCPD, but FSRA warns that opting out may not be best for you. Driving without valid insurance in Ontario can bring fines of $5,000 to $50,000, a licence suspension and an impounded car.
BC’s Basic Autoplan includes $200,000 of third-party liability, up to $200,000 of Basic Vehicle Damage Coverage when the other driver is at fault, Enhanced Accident Benefits with no overall limit, and Underinsured Motorist Protection up to $1 million per person.
Quebec law requires every car owner to have at least $50,000 of liability insurance for property damage, bought from a private insurer. The SAAQ plan covers injuries from a traffic accident anywhere in the world, whoever is responsible.
Tip: $200,000 of liability is the legal minimum, not a safe amount. FSRA suggests considering $1 million or $2 million, so you aren’t paying out of pocket if a serious crash costs more.
What changed in Ontario auto insurance on July 1, 2026?
If you buy a new Ontario policy on or after July 1, 2026, only medical, rehabilitation and attendant care benefits are mandatory. These accident benefits became optional:
- Income replacement and non-earner benefits
- Caregiver benefits and housekeeping and home maintenance
- Lost educational expenses and expenses of visitors
- Damage to personal items (like glasses or hearing aids)
- Death and funeral benefits
Other key points:
- Renewals: Existing policies renew with your current coverage unless you agree in writing to change it.
- Who is covered: Optional benefits now apply only to the named insured, their spouse, dependants and listed drivers. Other passengers, pedestrians and cyclists still get the mandatory benefits.
- Who pays first: Auto insurance now pays first for medical and rehabilitation costs (except medication), before your workplace or private health plan.
Watch out: Dropping income replacement lowers your premium, but if a crash stops you from working, you could have no income support. Many newcomers don’t have workplace disability coverage yet. Check what your job’s benefits cover before you remove anything.
How much does car insurance cost in Canada in 2026?
Ontario’s regulator publishes average premiums for all private passenger vehicles insured over the past 12 months:
| Region | As of June 2026 | As of October 2025 |
|---|---|---|
| Ontario (all) | $2,218 | $2,164 |
| Greater Toronto Area | $2,868 | $2,810 |
| Other urban Ontario | $2,131 | $2,076 |
| Rural Ontario | $1,791 | $1,740 |
In BC, the government announced no increase to ICBC Basic rates through spring 2027, seven years in a row without an increase. In Manitoba, MPI has asked for a 2.38% overall rate increase for 2027/28. Treat any average as a rough guide: newcomers can pay well above it in their first years. Budget for insurance before you buy a car, using our first-month budget guide.
12 legitimate ways to lower your car insurance premium
- Prove your driving history. Bring an official driving record and an insurer’s letter from home. ICBC credits up to 15 years, MPI may give a discount, and some private insurers will consider it.
- Get your provincial licence fast, then move up. In Ontario, drivers should get a 10% rate reduction on all coverages for one year when they reach G2 with a clean record, and again when they get their full G.
- Take a recognized driver training course. FSRA says most companies offer a discount to new drivers who complete one.
- Put on winter tires and ask for the discount. In Ontario, every insurer must offer a winter tire discount. They also make winter driving safer. See our first-winter guide.
- Try telematics. Usage-based insurance uses an app or device to price you on how you actually drive. Ask which insurers offer it.
- Raise your deductible. You pay more if you claim, but your premium goes down.
- Choose the car carefully. Vehicles that are often stolen or costly to repair cost more to insure. Check IBC’s How Cars Measure Up tool before you buy. In BC, cars with factory-installed automatic emergency braking get a 10% discount.
- Bundle your policies. Buying tenant or home insurance and car insurance from one company can save 5% to 15%. Insuring more than one car with one company can save 5% to 15% too.
- Pay in full if you can, and never miss a payment. Monthly plans can cost extra (ICBC charges a $15 enrolment fee plus interest). Policies cancelled for non-payment can push you into a higher-risk group.
- Drive less and list your use correctly. On annual policies, ICBC gives 10% off Basic for driving under 5,000 km a year, and 10% to 15% off some optional coverage under 15,000 km. Private insurers may discount low mileage or pleasure-only use.
- Ask about group discounts. Employers, unions, and professional or alumni associations sometimes have group rates.
- Don’t over-insure an old car. FSRA notes that collision and comprehensive coverage may not be worth it on a car worth less than $2,000.
The biggest saver over time is free: keep a clean record with no at-fault crashes or tickets.
How do you compare car insurance quotes and brokers?
In private-insurer provinces, you can buy from a broker (who compares several companies), an agent (who sells for one company), or a direct insurer (online or by phone). Use all three to get at least three quotes.
- Compare like with like. Same liability limit, same deductibles, same optional coverage.
- Ask the right questions. What exactly is covered? What is my deductible? How will one accident change my price? Which discounts do I get?
- Be completely honest. Wrong or missing information can let an insurer cancel your policy or refuse a claim.
- Time it well. Your renewal arrives about 30 days before it expires. Shop then, because cancelling mid-term can mean a penalty.
- Use free tools. In Ontario, FSRA’s Regulator Rate Ranger estimates what you might pay.
If every company says no, the Facility Association offers coverage in private-insurer provinces. In Quebec, Groupement des assureurs automobiles agents guarantee minimum liability coverage.
How do you avoid ghost broker and fake insurance scams?
A “ghost broker” pretends to be a licensed broker or agent and sells cheap policies or pink slips (proof-of-insurance cards) that are fake. Victims often learn the truth after a crash or a police stop, when they find they have no coverage. Be extra careful with “cheap insurance” offers sent through social media or messaging apps.
- Check the licence. In Ontario, use FSRA’s licence registry for agents and insurers, and Registered Insurance Brokers of Ontario (RIBO) for brokers. Other provinces have their own regulator or insurance council.
- Never pay in cash or by money transfer. FSRA warns against both.
- Call the insurer named on your policy to confirm it is real.
- Watch for red flags: cash-only requests, odd email addresses, documents that don’t match, or prices far below every other quote.
- After a crash, be suspicious if someone pressures you toward a specific body shop, clinic or lawyer.
If you think you’ve been scammed, keep every document, call the insurance company and the police, and report it to FSRA (in Ontario) or the Canadian Anti-Fraud Centre. A free settlement agency can help if you’re unsure who to call.
Frequently asked questions
Can I get car insurance in Canada with a foreign driver’s licence?
Rules vary by insurer and province, and many prefer a provincial licence. In Manitoba, MPI says to get your Manitoba licence before buying Autopac, or you can’t qualify for a premium discount. Getting your provincial licence early is the safest path.
Does ICBC accept driving experience from outside BC?
Yes. ICBC credits up to 15 years of non-learner experience from outside BC, using a driver’s abstract or letter of experience from the licensing authority that issued your first full licence. Proof of previous insurance isn’t required.
What is a letter of experience for car insurance?
It’s a letter from your previous insurer showing your policy dates, listed drivers and any claims. MPI says a claims history letter may help you get a discount. In Ontario and other private provinces, each insurer decides whether to use it.
What is the minimum car insurance in Ontario?
$200,000 of third-party liability, statutory accident benefits, uninsured automobile coverage and DCPD. For new policies since July 1, 2026, only medical, rehabilitation and attendant care benefits are mandatory.
What is the average cost of car insurance in Ontario in 2026?
FSRA reports $2,218 a year as of June 2026 for all of Ontario, and $2,868 in the Greater Toronto Area. Newcomers are often quoted more at first.
Should I drop income replacement in Ontario to save money?
You can, since it became optional on July 1, 2026. Think carefully first: if you have no workplace disability coverage, a crash could leave you with no income while you recover.
- Your average premium — Financial Services Regulatory Authority of Ontario
- How to save on auto insurance — FSRA
- What is in a standard auto insurance policy? — FSRA
- Fraud prevention and reporting — FSRA
- Ontario auto insurance changes — Insurance Bureau of Canada
- Mandatory auto insurance requirements — Insurance Bureau of Canada
- Insurance for new and returning residents — ICBC
- Basic insurance and Enhanced Care — ICBC
- New to Manitoba and your insurance — Manitoba Public Insurance
- Public Automobile Insurance Plan — SAAQ
- Automobile Insurance Act, sections 84 and 87 — LégisQuébec
- Automobile insurance — Government of Alberta
This guide is general information for newcomers and is not legal, tax, financial or immigration advice. Rules and amounts change, so always confirm with the official source linked above. Last reviewed November 2026.
